Obstetrics & Gynecology | Garnet Health
Obstetrics & Gynecology • Middletown, NY
Ratings by platform
- Healthgrades (Dr. Lillian Kaminsky): 1.7 out of 5 stars (40 ratings) (40 reviews)
- U.S. News & World Report (Provider profiles): 3.9 to 5 out of 5 stars (varies by provider) (Varies by provider)
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) quality assessment: 91.1 out of 100 (CMS quality score) (Not applicable (Institutional metric))
What patients say
Patients praise
- High praise for the clinical staff at the Rowley Family Birthing Center (nurses, doctors, and support staff)
- Reports of kind, professional, and knowledgeable care during delivery experiences
- Positive feedback on hospital food choices
Common complaints
- Reports of unprofessional, rude, or cold demeanor by some providers
- Difficulties with office staff, phone communication, and appointment scheduling
- Concerns about rushed appointments and lack of patient engagement
- Complaints regarding hospital amenities such as uncomfortable beds and spouse sleeping accommodations
- Mixed feedback on nursing staff performance
In patients' words
"Very cold and quick to rush you out of her office. And if you ask too many questions, she gets an attitude."
— Patient review of Ronica Bennett, CM (Healthgrades)"The staff is phenomenal. They are attentive, caring, and provide support. We had all 3 of our children delivered there."
— Patient review of Rowley Family Birthing Center (LocalityBiz)"Unprofessional, rude, unorganized, and constant problems is the summary of my experience. Do not waste your time going there."
— Patient review of Dr. Judith A. Stavis (Vitals)More clinics in Middletown
Middlesex Ob & Gyn Associates - RealPatientRatings
Patients praise: many patients express high satisfaction with individual providers, frequently describing them as kind, attentive, knowledgeable, and caring · praise for effective communication, thorough explanations, and good bedside manner, with patients feeling heard and not rushed by specific doctors and nurse practitioners.
Kettering Health Medical Group OB-GYN
Patients praise: Many patients describe providers as kind, gentle, and attentive with excellent bedside manner · High satisfaction ratings on official Kettering Health patient satisfaction surveys for specific OB-GYN locations.
Gynecology - Middletown Medical
Patients praise: Some providers are highly regarded by patients for their care and expertise · Specific mentions of positive clinical experiences and effective treatment outcomes.
Middlesex Health Crescent Street OB/GYN - Middletown
Patients praise: Some patients appreciate specific practitioners, such as APRN Elizabeth Fabrizi · Historical appreciation for the medical care provided by the doctors.
Obstetrics & Gynecology - | Crystal Run Healthcare
Patients praise: Many individual Ob-Gyn providers maintain high patient ratings (e.g., 4.9/5) · Some patients report professional and thorough care from specific doctors and staff.
Eye Care for RI: Eye Care and Vision Center - Middletown, RI
Patients praise: Professional and attentive doctors and staff · Comprehensive and thorough eye examinations.
Comparing your options?
Browse other Obstetrics & Gynecology clinics, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.