Orthopedic Shoulder Specialist | Orthopedic Doctors New Castle
Orthopaedics • New Castle, PA
Ratings by platform
- Healthgrades / UPMC Provider Directory: 5.0/5.0 (Healthgrades); 4.8/5.0 (UPMC Provider site) (4 reviews (Healthgrades); 84 reviews (UPMC site))
- Healthgrades: 2.7/5.0 (23 ratings)
- rater8 (Henry Community Health): 4.9/5.0 (Dr. Rolston); 5.0/5.0 (Dr. Mathews); 5.0/5.0 (Dr. Kaushik) (158 (Dr. Rolston); 50 (Dr. Mathews); ~25 (Dr. Kaushik - estimated based on available data))
What patients say
Patients praise
- Compassionate and attentive care
- Detailed explanations of conditions and procedures
- Professional and knowledgeable staff
- Successful surgical outcomes and recovery
- Welcoming clinic environment
Common complaints
- Poor bedside manner
- Inconsistent communication with patients
- Over-reliance on physician assistants instead of the primary surgeon
In patients' words
"Dr Singh was very friendly… great bedside manner… answered all my questions and concerns…understood my situation and my willingness to do everything possible to improve my shoulder aside from surgery."
— Healthgrades patient review for Dr. Neil Singh"He knows what he's doing, but has a terrible "bedside manner". Very quick and to the point."
— Healthgrades patient review for Dr. Robert McGann"He is willing to help you when others wouldn't. Very awesome, did not talk down me to because of my age... honest, communicates very well, is compassionate, caring and funny."
— rater8 patient review for Dr. Lindsey RolstonMore clinics in New Castle
Orthopedic Surgery in New Castle, PA - Find a UPMC Provider
Patients praise: High ratings for clinical knowledge, professionalism, and thoroughness of explanations · Staff often described as helpful and courteous.
Pain Management | Henry Community Health
Patients praise: Knowledgeable and professional staff · Excellent bedside manner and active listening skills.
Primary Care | Henry Community Health
Patients praise: Excellent nurse communication · High overall patient satisfaction with hospital cleanliness.
UPMC Heart and Vascular Institute | New Castle, Pa.
Patients praise: Professional and personable physicians and medical staff · High patient-reported ratings for individual providers (many averaging 4.7-4.9 stars).
Delaware Sports Medicine | Primary Care Sports Medicine In ...
Patients praise: Exceptional medical knowledge and diagnostic ability · Excellent bedside manner and personal care.
Pediatrics at New Castle Family and Internal Medicine
Patients praise: Providers are described as caring, attentive, and good listeners · Many patients appreciate the thoroughness and bedside manner of specific doctors and nurse practitioners.
Comparing your options?
Browse other Orthopedics clinics, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.

