Live
Read now
Dr. Thomas Mathews | New Castle, Indiana ... logo

Dr. Thomas Mathews | New Castle, Indiana ...

Orthopedic SurgeryNew Castle, IN

★★★★☆4.4/512 reviews across 2 platforms

Ratings by platform

  • Healthgrades: 5.0 out of 5 stars (5 reviews)
  • Vitals / WebMD: 4.0 out of 5 stars (7 ratings (with 2 written reviews))
  • rater8: Not explicitly stated (aggregated) (112 verified reviews)

What patients say

Patients praise

  • Caring bedside manner
  • Effective surgeon, particularly for knee replacements
  • Trustworthy and thorough in explaining treatments
  • Approachable and easy to talk to

Common complaints

  • No significant negative themes, complaints, or reports of negative experiences were found in the public search results.

In patients' words

"Doctor Matthews has performed numerous surgeries on me and i trust him implicitly. He is caring and takes all the necessary time explaining and reviewing everything. Top of the line doctor."

Vitals

"One of the best and most caring surgeons available.. I would recommend him to anyone having knee replacement.."

Vitals

"I know I'm always in good hands! ... Dr. Thomas Mathews is an awesome knee dr and a great person to speak with too."

Henry Community Health Patient Review

How these reviews were compiled

Synthesized from public patient-review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4][5][6][7].

More clinics in New Castle

Jason Allan Castle, MD | Vandalia Health

★★★★★4.9/5(181 reviews · 6 platforms)

Patients praise: Highly knowledgeable and skilled in joint replacement/orthopedic surgery · Clear explanations of conditions and treatment options.

New Castle, INOrthopedic Surgerypositive

Pain Management | Henry Community Health

★★★★★5.0/5(467 reviews · 3 platforms)

Patients praise: Knowledgeable and professional staff · Excellent bedside manner and active listening skills.

New Castle, INPain Medicinevery positive

Primary Care | Henry Community Health

★★★★★5.0/5(273 reviews · 3 platforms)

Patients praise: Excellent nurse communication · High overall patient satisfaction with hospital cleanliness.

New Castle, INEndocrinologypositive

UPMC Heart and Vascular Institute | New Castle, Pa.

★★★★★5.0/5(250 reviews · 2 platforms)

Patients praise: Professional and personable physicians and medical staff · High patient-reported ratings for individual providers (many averaging 4.7-4.9 stars).

New Castle, PAHeart & Vascular Caremixed

Delaware Sports Medicine | Primary Care Sports Medicine In ...

★★★★★5.0/5(99 reviews · 2 platforms)

Patients praise: Exceptional medical knowledge and diagnostic ability · Excellent bedside manner and personal care.

New Castle, DESports Medicinepositive

Pediatrics at New Castle Family and Internal Medicine

★★★★★5.0/5(65 reviews · 2 platforms)

Patients praise: Providers are described as caring, attentive, and good listeners · Many patients appreciate the thoroughness and bedside manner of specific doctors and nurse practitioners.

New Castle, INPediatricsmixed

See all clinics in New Castle

Comparing your options?

Browse other Orthopedics clinics, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.

More Orthopedics clinics