Live
Read now
Brooks-TLC Hospital System, Inc. logo

Brooks-TLC Hospital System, Inc.

Orthopaedic Surgery • Chautauqua, NY

★★★☆☆3.0/557 reviews across 3 platforms

Ratings by platform

  • U.S. News & World Report: 3/5
  • Healthgrades: 59% recommend
  • Facebook: 64% recommend (57 reviews)

What patients say

Patients praise

  • Positive experiences specifically reported for orthopedic surgeries, including hip replacements and discectomies
  • Appreciation for having specialized orthopedic surgical capabilities available locally in Chautauqua County
  • Specific mentions of surgeon competence, humor, and effective communication in orthopedic contexts
  • Overall hospital patient satisfaction scores in some surveys fall within moderate to acceptable ranges (e.g., 62-64% recommendation rate)

Common complaints

  • Concerns regarding staff communication and responsiveness in the ER
  • Reports of perceived condescending or dismissive bedside manner from some providers
  • Frustration with long wait times and perceived lack of urgency for certain conditions
  • General patient dissatisfaction regarding perceived quality of care, specifically in non-orthopedic contexts
  • Challenges regarding access to local specialty services due to hospital resource shifts (e.g., maternity unit closures)

In patients' words

"My quality of life has improved significantly and my recovery went very well... Dr. Shephard’s sense of humor eased my nerves. I recommend him and already gave a coworker his office number!"

— Patient testimonial regarding hip replacement at Brooks-TLC

"After seeing Dr. Kukreja, I had a Lumbar Discectomy within a month... I was walking the day after my surgery, pain-free. His care and expertise made all the difference."

— Patient testimonial regarding orthopedic surgery at Brooks-TLC

"This hospital is absolutely disgusting with how they treat their customers... the staff was literally sitting around joking barely doing their job."

— Negative review regarding ER experience

How these reviews were compiled

Synthesized from public patient-review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4][5][6].

More clinics in Chautauqua

Lakeshore Orthopedics & Sports Medicine

★★★★★4.8/5(48 reviews · 3 platforms)

Patients praise: High praise for surgical outcomes and professional expertise, particularly for Dr. Fitzgerald and Dr. Mata · Supportive and knowledgeable office staff noted in some positive reviews.

Chautauqua, NYOrthopaedic Surgerymixed

Brian A. Mata, MD

★★★★★4.7/5(538 reviews · 6 platforms)

Patients praise: Courteous/professional staff and good bedside manner · Explains conditions/treatment options clearly; listens to questions.

Chautauqua, NYOrthopaedic Surgerymixed

Optum Ear, Nose and Throat

★★★★★5.0/5(30,124 reviews · 2 platforms)

Patients praise: Professional, caring, and thorough medical staff · Clear explanations of conditions and treatments.

Chautauqua, NYEar, Nose, & Throatpositive

North Chautauqua Dental

★★★★★5.0/5(100 reviews · 1 platform)

Patients praise: Friendly, helpful, and personable staff · Modern, clean, and high-tech facility.

Chautauqua, NYDentalpositive

Chautauqua Medical Aesthetics

★★★★★5.0/5(56 reviews · 1 platform)

Patients praise: Professional, friendly, and knowledgeable staff · Clean, beautiful, and welcoming office environment.

Chautauqua, NYMedical Aestheticsvery positive

Chautauqua Lake Dental

★★★★★5.0/5(30 reviews · 1 platform)

Patients praise: Professional, caring, and patient staff · Beautiful, clean, and state-of-the-art facility.

Chautauqua, NYDentalvery positive

See all clinics in Chautauqua →

Comparing your options?

Browse other Orthopedics clinics, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.

More Orthopedics clinics