Live
Read now
NY Orthopedics logo

NY Orthopedics

Orthopedics • Staten Island, NY

★★★★★4.8/5435 reviews across 5 platforms

Ratings by platform

  • Healthgrades: 4.9/5 (264 reviews)
  • WebMD Care: 5.0/5 (69 reviews)
  • WebMD Care: 4.5/5 (44 reviews)
  • RateMDs: 4.9/5 (33 reviews)
  • Healthgrades: 4.2/5 (25 reviews)

What patients say

Patients praise

  • high level of professional expertise and knowledge
  • compassionate and attentive bedside manner
  • effective communication of treatment plans and options
  • conservative approach prioritizing non-surgical treatments where appropriate
  • helpful and professional office staff
  • successful outcomes for surgeries and procedures

Common complaints

  • occasional long wait times in office
  • perceived lack of attentiveness or failure to identify pain sources in some patient experiences
  • general patient frustration with doctors not listening to pain complaints

In patients' words

"Dr. McCulloch is one of the best! Great bedside manner, took all the time I needed to make me understand everything that needed to be treated. Great results. Great with documentation, and one of the best staff I've ever dealt with."

— New York Sports & Joints patient testimonial

"Kudos to the staff at Dr Montalbano’s office! They are the most professional and at the same time, the most heartwarming group of Professionals by far. A huge thank you to Dr. MONTALBANO for diagnosing my hip injury and treating it with an overwhelming result!"

— RateMDs review for Dr. Gregory Montalbano

"Spent almost 2 hours waiting and had to leave without seeing the doctor."

— RateMDs review for Dr. John C. L'Insalata

How these reviews were compiled

Synthesized from public patient-review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4][5][6][7].

More clinics in Staten Island

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

★★★★☆4.3/5(361 reviews · 1 platform)

Patients praise: Competent and knowledgeable medical staff and surgeons · Efficient diagnostic services like on-site X-rays and timely MRI results.

Staten Island, NYOrthopedicsmixed

Grasmere Physical Therapy

★★★★★5.0/5(40 reviews · 1 platform)

Patients praise: Knowledgeable and professional staff · Welcoming, family-like atmosphere.

Staten Island, NYPhysical Therapyvery positive

Mount Sinai Doctors on Staten Island

★★★★★4.9/5(2,130 reviews · 4 platforms)

Patients praise: Professionalism and knowledge of doctors · Clear explanation of conditions and diagnoses.

Staten Island, NYCardiologypositive

Mount Sinai Doctors-Staten Island, Endocrinology

★★★★★4.9/5(737 reviews · 2 platforms)

Patients praise: Highly recommended by patients · Clear explanation of treatment options.

Staten Island, NYEndocrinologypositive

Mount Sinai Doctors on Staten Island

★★★★★4.9/5(665 reviews · 2 platforms)

Patients praise: Many patients praise the doctors for being knowledgeable, thorough, and compassionate · Staff are often described as friendly and professional in direct interactions.

Staten Island, NYFamily Medicinemixed

Pain Treatment Specialists

★★★★★4.9/5(490 reviews · 6 platforms)

Patients praise: Compassionate, professional, and knowledgeable care · Effective, life-changing treatment outcomes for chronic pain.

Staten Island, NYPain Managementpositive

See all clinics in Staten Island →

Comparing your options?

Browse other Orthopedics clinics, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.

More Orthopedics clinics