Live
Read now
Orthopedic & Sports Medicine Doctors in Staten Island logo

Orthopedic & Sports Medicine Doctors in Staten Island

OrthopedicsStaten Island, NY

★★★★★4.8/5435 reviews across 5 platforms

Ratings by platform

  • Healthgrades: 4.9/5 (264)
  • WebMD Care: 5.0/5 (69)
  • WebMD Care: 4.5/5 (44)
  • RateMDs: 4.9/5 (33)
  • Healthgrades: 4.2/5 (25)

What patients say

Patients praise

  • high level of professional expertise and knowledge
  • compassionate and attentive bedside manner
  • effective communication of treatment plans and options
  • conservative approach prioritizing non-surgical treatments where appropriate
  • helpful and professional office staff
  • successful outcomes for surgeries and procedures

Common complaints

  • occasional long wait times in office
  • perceived lack of attentiveness or failure to identify pain sources in some patient experiences
  • general patient frustration with doctors not listening to pain complaints

In patients' words

"Dr. McCulloch is one of the best! Great bedside manner, took all the time I needed to make me understand everything that needed to be treated. Great results. Great with documentation, and one of the best staff I've ever dealt with."

New York Sports & Joints patient testimonial

"Kudos to the staff at Dr Montalbano’s office! They are the most professional and at the same time, the most heartwarming group of Professionals by far. A huge thank you to Dr. MONTALBANO for diagnosing my hip injury and treating it with an overwhelming result!"

RateMDs review for Dr. Gregory Montalbano

"Spent almost 2 hours waiting and had to leave without seeing the doctor."

RateMDs review for Dr. John C. L'Insalata

How these reviews were compiled

Synthesized from public patient-review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4][5][6][7].

More clinics in Staten Island

Staten Island: 3333 Hylan Blvd. - Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group

★★★★☆4.3/5(361 reviews · 1 platforms)

Patients praise: Competent and knowledgeable medical staff and surgeons · Efficient diagnostic services like on-site X-rays and timely MRI results.

Staten Island, NYOrthopedicsmixed

Grasmere Physical Therapy: Physical Therapy in Staten Island ...

★★★★★5.0/5(40 reviews · 1 platforms)

Patients praise: Knowledgeable and professional staff · Welcoming, family-like atmosphere.

Staten Island, NYPhysical Therapyvery positive

Cardiology - Mount Sinai Doctors on Staten Island

★★★★★4.9/5(2,130 reviews · 4 platforms)

Patients praise: Professionalism and knowledge of doctors · Clear explanation of conditions and diagnoses.

Staten Island, NYCardiologypositive

Mount Sinai Doctors-Staten Island, Endocrinology

★★★★★4.9/5(737 reviews · 2 platforms)

Patients praise: Highly recommended by patients · Clear explanation of treatment options.

Staten Island, NYEndocrinologypositive

Primary Care - Mount Sinai Doctors on Staten Island

★★★★★4.9/5(665 reviews · 2 platforms)

Patients praise: Many patients praise the doctors for being knowledgeable, thorough, and compassionate · Staff are often described as friendly and professional in direct interactions.

Staten Island, NYFamily Medicinemixed

Pain treatment in Staten Island, NY | Trusted Pain Specialists

★★★★★4.9/5(490 reviews · 6 platforms)

Patients praise: Compassionate, professional, and knowledgeable care · Effective, life-changing treatment outcomes for chronic pain.

Staten Island, NYPain Managementpositive

See all clinics in Staten Island

Comparing your options?

Browse other Orthopedics clinics, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.

More Orthopedics clinics