Mercy Health — Orthopedics and Sports Medicine, Oxford
Sports Medicine • Oxford, OH
Ratings by platform
- Vitals, WebMD, OrthopedicPRP, MDSave: 3.9/5 (Vitals), 4/5 (OrthopedicPRP), 4.3/5 (MDSave aggregate for area providers) (Very limited individual reviews for the specific location; 2 reviews for Dr. Rottinghaus on WebMD)
What patients say
Patients praise
- Expertise in sports medicine and musculoskeletal injuries
- Comprehensive care approach including physical therapy and strength training
- Services for Miami University intercollegiate athletics and the general community
Common complaints
- Concerns regarding patient follow-up and dismissal of symptoms
- Perceived lack of attentiveness to patient's active lifestyle
- Disagreements regarding physical therapy and treatment necessity
In patients' words
"Would not recommend Dr. Rottinghaus. Before my knee injury I was a very active person, and I do not believe Dr. Rottinghaus took that seriously... I’m a year out from my injury and I still have visible swelling."
— WebMD (Dr. Brian Rottinghaus review)More clinics in Oxford
Orthopedic Surgeons in Oxford, OH - MDsave
Patients praise: positive bedside manner and communication skills · clear explanations of treatment options.
Injury Care, Walk-In Care, and More in Oxford - Campbell Clinic
Patients praise: High satisfaction with specific providers, particularly Physician Assistants like Cristina Leis · Appreciation for professional, knowledgeable, and caring bedside manner among many staff members.
Urgent Care in Oxford, Mississippi | Walk-in Clinic
Patients praise: Friendly, compassionate, and professional staff · Efficient service with relatively short wait times.
Specialty Orthopedic Group - Oxford
Patients praise: High ratings on some review platforms regarding overall care and professionalism · Physicians praised for technical expertise and clear explanations of treatment plans.
Kettering Health Oxford Health Center
Patients praise: Kettering Health states its patient experience ratings are based on surveys from actual verified patients and uses Press Ganey survey methodology, which is intended to reflect real experiences · Kettering Health positions Oxford Health Center as providing compassionate/faith-based care to the Oxford community.
Injury Care, Walk-In Care, and More in Oxford
Patients praise: Friendly, professional, and helpful staff · Quick wait times for some patients.
Comparing your options?
Browse other Sports Medicine clinics, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.

