
Women's Health Center - Carlisle Regional Medical Center
Women's Health • Carlisle, PA
Ratings by platform
- Birdeye (UPMC Magee-Womens at UPMC Carlisle): 4.4/5 stars (16 reviews)
- Birdeye (UPMC Divine Mercy Womens Health): 3.4/5 stars (18 reviews)
- UPMC Provider Profile (Dr. Mary Elizabeth Higgins): 4.8/5 stars (13 reviews (41 ratings))
- UPMC Provider Profile (Caroline Gindhart, CRNP): 4.7/5 stars (39 reviews (129 ratings),)
What patients say
Patients praise
- high praise for individual providers (physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants) regarding bedside manner, compassion, and listening skills
- favorable ratings for birth and gynecological care experiences overall
- patients feel heard, seen, and valued by specific clinical staff
Common complaints
- concerns regarding administrative/front-desk staff professionalism and communication
- occasional reports of long wait times
- isolated reports of facility hygiene issues
In patients' words
"We had such a wonderful experience at UPMCS Magee-Womens in Carlisle... Our care both during labor and after delivery was 5 stars."
— Birdeye review for UPMC Magee-Womens at UPMC Carlisle"The genuine love, compassion and concern was felt from the moment Alyssa walked in the room. She was AMAZING... I felt heard and seen as a black woman."
— UPMC Provider Profile review for Alyssa Shedlock Bretz, PA-C"Around 24 hours after birth we found bed bugs in our room and had to be switched... Absolutely unacceptable."
— Birdeye review for UPMC Magee-Womens at UPMC Carlisle"I believe that my Dr was very knowledgeable and meant well, but the general feeling of the room felt like she was not interested in my problems, and her [demeanor] was slightly condescending."
— UPMC Provider Profile review for Caroline Gindhart, CRNPMore clinics in Carlisle
Carlisle, Pa. - Women's Health Locations - UPMC
Patients praise: High praise for specific doctors and individual providers (e.g., Dr. Momon-Nelson, Dr. Higgins) · Strong support for nursing and maternity care staff in labor and delivery.
Women's Health & Pregnancy - Dunham Army Health Clinic
Patients praise: Clean, well-maintained, and welcoming facility environment · Staff generally described as professional and pleasant by many patients.
Carlisle - Orthopedic Institute of Pennsylvania - OIP
Patients praise: Convenient walk-in injury clinic services · Efficient and fast imaging (MRI/X-ray) services.
Internal Medicine Provider | Sleep Medicine Doctor Located in ...
Patients praise: Providers are attentive listeners and compassionate · Clear explanations of conditions and treatment plans.
General Surgery in Carlisle, PA - Find a UPMC Provider
Patients praise: Professional and thorough provider communication · High satisfaction scores for outpatient surgery facilities and staff.
Wound Care in Carlisle, PA - ProviderMatch - Find a UPMC Provider
Patients praise: Very high provider ratings for wound care (4.9/5) · Clinicians explain wound condition/procedures clearly and thoroughly.
Comparing your options?
Browse other clinics in Carlisle, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.

