General Surgery | Penn Highlands Healthcare
General Surgery • State College, PA
Ratings by platform
- Healthgrades (for Dr. Matthew Davidson, General Surgery): 4.8 out of 5 stars (9 reviews)
- Birdeye (for Penn Highlands State College Emergency Department): 4.3 out of 5 stars (6 reviews)
What patients say
Patients praise
- Doctors described as caring, attentive, and good listeners
- Staff praised for being professional and compassionate in many patient encounters
- Patients reported feeling heard and having clear treatment plans
Common complaints
- Reports of dismissive or irritated staff attitudes during certain visits, particularly in emergency contexts
- Specific complaints regarding long wait times and lack of communication from staff in the emergency department
In patients' words
"Wonderful surgeon! Informative, patient and caring. Would recommend him to anyone... He takes the time to answer all questions, silly or not."
— Healthgrades (Dr. Matthew Davidson)"The staff, nurse, and physician were very caring, personable, and they really listened... We left the ER with answers and a plan."
— Birdeye (Penn Highlands State College ER review)"Everyone was very mean, could tell they were irritated that I was there around midnight, told me multiple times they don't know how to work..."
— Facebook group discussion regarding experiences at the facilityMore clinics in State College
General Surgery | Penn State Health
Patients praise: High provider satisfaction ratings for individual general surgeons, often around 4.9 out of 5 stars · Patients describing surgeons as informative, patient, and caring.
General Surgery | Mount Nittany Health
Patients praise: High patient satisfaction ratings for individual general surgeons · Providers described as caring, knowledgeable, and thorough.
Matthew Hazey, MD | Dermatology | State College, PA
Patients praise: Professionalism · Knowledgeable.
Penn State Health Sports Medicine and Physical Therapy
Patients praise: High patient satisfaction ratings for individual providers (e.g., 4.9/5) · Professional, knowledgeable, and attentive medical staff.
Neurology | Penn State Health
Patients praise: High patient satisfaction ratings for some individual neurologists · Knowledgeable and professional care for many patients.
Primary Care | Mount Nittany Health
Patients praise: Physicians frequently described as thorough, kind, and knowledgeable · Patients appreciate doctors who listen and address concerns without rushing.
Comparing your options?
Browse other clinics in State College, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.