Live
Read now
New York Comprehensive Medical Care logo

New York Comprehensive Medical Care

Family Medicine • Smithtown, NY

★★★★★4.8/5352 reviews across 3 platforms

Ratings by platform

  • Yahoo Local: 3.0/5 (10 reviews)
  • Birdeye: 4.9/5 (57 reviews)
  • Zocdoc: 4.89/5 (285 reviews)

What patients say

Patients praise

  • Thorough and knowledgeable doctors (specifically Dr. Pilip and Dr. Nayyar)
  • Compassionate bedside manner
  • Efficient and fast appointments
  • Helpful and friendly office staff
  • Convenient walk-in availability and 7-day operation

Common complaints

  • Administrative issues regarding payment methods for appointments
  • Challenges in obtaining medical records when moving abroad

In patients' words

"Dr. Nayyar has been our doctor for years, and we truly could not ask for better care. He is incredibly knowledgeable and always takes a thorough, thoughtful approach to every visit."

— Birdeye Review

How these reviews were compiled

Synthesized from public patient-review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8].

More clinics in Smithtown

Family Medicine in Smithtown, NY - ProviderMatch - Catholic Health

★★★★★4.9/5(1,118 reviews · 3 platforms)

Patients praise: High ratings for individual family medicine providers in the Catholic Health network (generally 4.8-5.0 out of 5 stars) · Online scheduling availability via ProviderMatch.

Smithtown, NYFamily Medicinepositive

Beauty BOMB Aesthetics

★★★★★5.0/5(750 reviews · 2 platforms)

Patients praise: Knowledgeable and thoughtful staff, specifically praising founder Christine Gerena, PA-C · Personalized and customized treatment plans.

Smithtown, NYMed Spa/Aestheticspositive

Gastroenterology in Smithtown, NY - ProviderMatch - Catholic Health

★★★★★5.0/5(470 reviews · 3 platforms)

Patients praise: kind and caring demeanor · thorough and informative explanations.

Smithtown, NYGastroenterologypositive

Professional Physical Therapy Clinic

★★★★★5.0/5(402 reviews · 1 platform)

Patients praise: Attentive and friendly staff · Effective treatment and rehabilitation results.

Smithtown, NYPhysical Therapypositive

VITRA Aesthetics Clinic

★★★★★5.0/5(286 reviews · 1 platform)

Patients praise: professional and knowledgeable staff · clean, tranquil, and luxurious atmosphere.

Smithtown, NYMed Spa/Aestheticspositive

Smithtown Wellness

★★★★★5.0/5(76 reviews · 1 platform)

Patients praise: Compassionate, knowledgeable, and thorough care provided by Dr. Scott Brunengraber · Effective chiropractic and holistic treatments for various conditions including pain, anxiety, and wellness maintenance.

Smithtown, NYChiropracticvery positive

See all clinics in Smithtown →

Comparing your options?

Browse other Family Medicine clinics, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.

More Family Medicine clinics