Obstetrics & Gynecology - Western Montana Clinic
Obstetrics & Gynecology • Missoula, MT
Ratings by platform
- Birdeye (Western Montana Clinic overall): 2.9/5 (144 reviews) (144 reviews)
- RateMDs (Dr. Jennifer Mayo): 4.2/5 (16 reviews) (16 reviews)
- RateMDs (Dr. Janice Givler): 3.4/5 (10 reviews) (10 reviews)
- Birdeye (Dr. Tondy Baumgartner): 4.8/5 (42 reviews) (42 reviews)
What patients say
Patients praise
- Highly skilled and confident surgical capabilities
- Compassionate, kind, and professional bedside manner from many providers
- Effective communication and responsiveness through patient portals
- Strong patient advocacy and validation of concerns
- Supportive during pregnancy and delivery experiences
Common complaints
- Poor communication regarding staff changes and scheduling
- Difficulty securing timely appointments
- Concerns regarding C-section rates for certain providers
- Reports of impersonal or hurried bedside manner
- Isolated complaints regarding surgical outcomes and patient advocacy
In patients' words
"Tondy is hands down the best doctor/medical team... I always looked forward to them... She listened to every concern."
— Birdeye (Dr. Tondy Baumgartner)"She is so kind, compassionate and has good bedside manners. She is a very skilled and confident OB/Gyn."
— RateMDs (Dr. Jennifer Mayo)"As others have noted, I have been a patient at Western Montana Clinic for 30 years. However, they laid off my primary provider and now indicate that they have no providers accepting 'new patients.'"
— Birdeye (Western Montana Clinic)"If you have any desire for a vaginal birth, AVOID HER... I am sure she is a smart, skilled surgeon, but surgery is the last resort in birth, not the first."
— Vitals (Dr. Janice Givler)More clinics in Missoula
Providence Advanced Gynecology, Missoula
Patients praise: high satisfaction with some individual providers · professional and knowledgeable interactions (historically).
Women's Health Services | OBGYN | Missoula, MT
Patients praise: Compassionate, intelligent, and skilled medical care · Positive experiences with prenatal, birthing, and postpartum support.
Internal Medicine Services | Missoula, MT Internists
Patients praise: Excellent bedside manner and compassion · Thorough, knowledgeable, and proactive medical care.
Primary Care Doctors in Missoula, MT
Patients praise: Exceptional listening skills and empathetic bedside manner · Thorough and knowledgeable care.
Sentinel Health: Missoula's Premier Direct Primary Care Clinic ...
Patients praise: Kind, professional, and attentive staff · Highly accessible providers with direct communication (same-day access).
Broadway Internal Medicine - Missoula, MT | Providence
Patients praise: High overall clinic rating (e.g., 4.9/5 on official site) · Providers described as knowledgeable, thorough, and compassionate.
Comparing your options?
Browse other Obstetrics & Gynecology clinics, or filter by state and specialty to compare patient ratings.